Overall, the Blue Jays acquired an average long-reliever and backup catcher for an extra bullpen piece and the Phillies acquired a valuable setup man for a lacking backstop and a minor prospect.
Blue Jays - B
Phillies - B+
For more info on the trade see: http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2013/12/phillies-acquire-brad-lincoln.html
Image citations in order of page: